Research questions
Define which observable listing characteristics are being studied and avoid inferring sales or buyer behavior from content alone.
Research plan
The research plan sets out how to study listing clarity, supporting evidence, product statements, and the order of content.
Protocol components
Define the sample and the measures in advance so readers can understand what the study covers.
Define which observable listing characteristics are being studied and avoid inferring sales or buyer behavior from content alone.
Specify markets, platforms, categories, dates, inclusion rules, exclusions, and how listings will be selected.
Define how reviewers record dimensions, package contents, evidence for statements, the purpose of images, and visible limitations.
Use reviewer training, double coding, disagreement handling, versioned instruments, and a transparent missing-data policy.
Proposed research sequence
Approve the study plan, rights review, and resources before starting to collect listings.
Publish the questions, definitions, sampling rules, exclusions, analysis plan, and expected limitations before collection.
Record platform, market, category, observation date, selection path, and any unavailable or duplicate listings.
Pilot the coding guide on a separate set, revise ambiguous variables, and measure reviewer agreement.
Record only what a reviewer can see and substantiate; do not infer conversion, sales, seller intent, or product truth.
Report sample sizes, missing data, distributions, reviewer agreement, checks on assumptions, and differences between categories.
Release the review guide, methodology, collection dates, limitations, corrections process, and aggregate data that can be shared.
Measurement criteria
Reviewers look for an exact measurement with units in the listing text, specifications, or images.
Listing review criteria
Exact dimensions visible in seller-controlled copy, specifications, or an image, with units that a reviewer can record.
Phrases such as compact, large, spacious, or fits anywhere without an observable measurement.
Present, absent, ambiguous, or not applicable, with a note field for reviewer uncertainty.
Presence of dimensions does not establish accuracy, buyer comprehension, conversion impact, or marketplace quality.
Scope of the study
The study will report how often reviewers observe each listing feature in the chosen sample.
Record the sample selection rules and collection dates with any published findings.
Include sample sizes and uncertainty with comparisons between categories or marketplaces.
The measures describe listing content. Product quality, sales, conversion, and satisfaction need separate evidence.
Future collection must address platform terms, copyright, privacy, sampling bias, missing data, and reviewer agreement.
Any future report must separate pre-registered analysis from exploratory findings and publish material corrections.
Next step
Use the checklist to review measurements, package contents, and supporting evidence in the listing you are working on.